171 Following

rameau's ramblings

A reader who’ll try anything once, including bad books in search of good ones. Eclectic as her tastes are, she tends to gravitate to historical romances, realistic contemporaries, and some fantasy novels.

Currently reading

The Complete Sherlock Holmes (The Heirloom Collection)
Arthur Conan Doyle, Simon Vance
Progress: 13 %
Jaakko Hämeen-Anttila

Hellfire (Theirs Not To Reason Why #3) by Jean Johnson

Hellfire (Theirs Not to Reason Why) - Jean Johnson

I should read more scifi, I think, but I never do. Why? Because whenever I'm reading scifi I feel like a failure as a physics student for not understanding it all. Which is why whenever I pick up a Jean Johnson novel I leave my scientific brain at the door.


I won't think too deeply about this, no I won't. Except that doesn't work either.


Hellfire is the third and the middle—I am told—book of Theirs Not to Reason Why-series. It felt a touch unfinished. I had some issues with the pacing and I guess that could be explained by the author extending the series with one book. The middle part was heavy on the battle sequences and somewhat jumpy with the date and scene changes. I liked the beginning where Ia once again visits her family on Sanctuary and the ending with a sliver of character development best.


Over and over I've said I'm a plot girl but—and here comes the caveat—not at the expense of the characters. There's very little on Ia's personal growth in any of the three books published so far. She has this huge task that's literally bigger than any one life, even hers, but she's holding it together and converting people into her way of thinking. There's hardly anything on how she copes with the pressure or a failure.


In An Officer's Duty Ia met Meyun Harper, her own blind spot, the one person whose future she can't see and she had to learn to work around that. In Hellfire there's a moment where Ia and her crew fail to fulfil one of her visions and the cost is great. She muddles along and finds a way to duck tape the frayed threads of time together. but the personal side of that failure and recovery is all but ignored. Instead, it's used as a way for Ia to solidify the trust and faith of her crew. She isn't shown to learn from her mistakes and plan for extra contingencies.


It could be said that the cost for any of her mistakes is too great, but compared to the extinction of the Milky Way? I really hope this is explored further, but I fear the author has moved on.


What ever happens, I hope the next book has more Meyun Harper in it.